Wednesday, March 19, 2014

Governor Blames School Cuts on Phantom Deficit

Governor Corbett has taken a lot of heat for cutting nearly a billion dollars from education during his first year in office, money he has not yet replenished.  Recently, the Governor explained that this was necessary due to the $4 billion deficit he inherited from the Rendell Administration.  In fact, it’s a claim he’s made since first taking office: due to expiring stimulus money and irresponsible spending, he was forced to make cuts due to the giant deficit he was handed.  However, numbers revealed by the state government tell a different story.  According to the Governor’s Budget Office, he actually entered office with a billion dollar surplus in the General Fund.  There are many reasons why the Corbett Administration may have cut education funding, but balancing out a budget deficit was not one of them.

The $4 billion deficit claim is one the Governor has made often, with the AP reporting in March 2011 that “Corbett lashed out at what he called a credit-card culture in state government that left him with no choice but to cut his way out of a projected $4 billion deficit…He attacked his predecessor, Democrat Ed Rendell, for using temporary federal recession aid to increase education spending.”  He’s now released a new ad that claims, “When I ran for governor, I promised you I was going to change Harrisburg, and boy, have we. Harrisburg's job-crushing $4.2 billion deficit is now gone.”  It is true that it is gone; it was never there in the first place.  Even new SRC appointee Farah Jimenez is repeating the company line, telling Newsworks, “If you look back, the funding crisis is a more recent occurrence, it happened after the economic stimulus funding from the federal government was no longer available to us.  Prior to that, the level of monies that we had available to educate our kids is pretty much similar to what we have now.”  Except, of course, for everything Governor Corbett cut out.

So let’s look at the real numbers.  According to the Governor’s Executive Budget 2013-2014, the “Actual Beginning Balance” (their words) for 2011-12 was $1.1 billion carried over from Governor Rendell’s last year in office.  Going back to his 2012-2013 budget, the General Fund listed the same $1.1 billion surplus as Harrisburg’s “Available Beginning Balance.”  In fact, by the time Governor Corbett took office, revenues had returned to pre-recession levels.  They are currently about a billion dollars above where they were then.  So all those education cuts are going to be restored, right?  Unlikely.  Because the truth of the matter is that the Governor cut nearly a billion dollars from education for other reasons.  He needed to cover a $450 million business tax cut while still being able to tout a year end surplus of more than $600 million, so something had to go.  Despite what he and his appointees claim, there was no $4 billion deficit he had to deal with.  His own budget says as much, over and over again.  Budget crunches often force executives and legislators to make tough decisions.  But not this time.

Thursday, February 13, 2014

Governor Corbett's Proposed Budget: Too Many Strings Attached for Schools

Governor Corbett recently announced his 2014-15 budget, and its focal point is an increase in education spending.  But a solution to Pennsylvania’s public school funding crisis it is not.  In fact, not only is it short of where it needs to be to meet the needs of our students, it’s still short of where it was before he cut $1 billion from it when he first took office.  The Governor’s proposal is a good place to start the budget conversation, but with early childhood education funding still 10% below pre-cut levels and grant-based regulations preventing school districts from directing the money where it’s most needed–not to mention questions about its feasibility, it cannot be the end of the conversation.

Nearly all of the new funding comes in the form of a new, $241 million “Ready to Learn” block grant program that uses a transparent formula to allocate funds to districts.  It’s a good sign that they will use a formula based on number of students, English language learners and concentration of poverty, but there’s a catch.  Poor, low performing districts will be handcuffed in how they can spend the funds.  The state is restricting the use of the funds to STEM education, tutoring and efforts to boost early literacy.  All good ideas, but it means that the school basics of rehiring classroom teachers to return class sizes to normal, nurses, counselors and librarians can’t be paid for with these funds.  Meanwhile, wealthier districts like Lower Merion will get to choose how they spend the money, with possibilities “including expanding pre-K options, extending the kindergarten school day or offering supplemental instruction in biology, English and algebra,” according to Newsworks.

The School District of Philadelphia looks to get $29 million from the block grant program.  Not only does this money come earmarked, it barely comes at all.  “The beleaguered district needs any money it can get,” the Inquirer reports, “but the new funds will not fill the hole of more than $100 million created by nonrecurring money in this year’s spending plan.”  That hole cannot be filled without additional money added to the basic education subsidy, which represents the majority of the state’s support of the district, a solution absent from the Governor’s plan.

The early education portion of Corbett’s proposal features a $10 million boost to Pre-K Counts, which could cover services for 1,670 children.  However, the Child Care Subsidy, which accounts for the vast majority of early childhood funding, is still down more than $60 million dollars from 2010-11.  That leaves early childhood education still well behind where it was when the Governor took office.


Of course, all this comes with a pretty big question.  Can the state actually find the money without raising taxes, as the Governor hopes?  “Corbett's budget plan banks on hundreds of millions of dollars in savings from yet-to-be-approved initiatives,” the Inquirer points out.  “One would rein in the cost of public-employee pensions by postponing payments until later years; another would make changes to the state's Medicaid program. The latter requires federal approval.  Both are big ifs.”  Increasing funding is a step in the right direction, as is beginning to implement a formula for education.  But ultimately this proposal needs to be a starting out point, as it does not go far enough in restoring the Governor’s cuts to education and prevents districts from using the funding in the most important ways.  Ultimately, though, it might not matter.  If the precarious funding plan is as unlikely as it seems, this might all be moot.  And it will be Pennsylvania’s children that pay the price.

Thursday, January 30, 2014

Pre-K Works, but Only for Those with Access

The amount of public funding available for Pre-K in Pennsylvania covers less than 20 percent of the 3-and-4-year-olds that need it.  The annual cost of private pre-k can rival the cost of college tuition, forcing too many families to go without a high-quality program essential to their children’s success.  Public concern over the shortage of high quality pre-k is clearly something that elected officials and candidates are beginning to notice.  Again, the President called for federal investment in pre-k in the 2014 State of the Union Address.  Similarly, New York Mayor Bill de Balsio rallied voters to his side in part by emphasizing his commitment to pre-k.  According to a new poll commissioned by the Economy League of Greater Philadelphia, Pennsylvania voters overwhelmingly favor increased spending on pre-k, even at the expense of raised taxes.  With every House seat up for election, not to mention many Senate seats in the southeast and a Governor’s race that might hinge on that area; this is the best chance for the Philadelphia area’s children to gain access to high-quality pre-k.

The poll finds that nearly two-thirds of Pennsylvanians support increasing funding to ensure all children have access to voluntary, high quality pre-k programs, with more than half of voters strongly supporting it.  And they are willing to raise their taxes to do so, by a more than two to one margin. This is not a partisan issue, a majority of Democrats, Republicans and independents support expanding access to high-quality pre-k programs.

Voters recognize how important it is for children to arrive at kindergarten ready to learn and are ready to make that knowledge visible on Election Day.  The poll finds that Pennsylvania voters consider education as one of the most important issues for elected officials to focus on, second only to the economy.  Most importantly, more than 40 percent of voters say that are more likely to vote for a candidate who favored increasing funding for pre-k programs, with almost as many saying they are less likely to vote for a candidate who opposed increasing funding.  If our representatives in Harrisburg aren’t willing to do anything about this, then their replacements will be.

This poll is evidence of the wisdom of PCCY’s effort to help form a broad, statewide coalition fighting to make high-quality pre-k a visible issue during this critical election year and beyond.  “When all children arrive ready to learn, they are best able to take advantage of the educational benefits of classroom learning,” said Upper Darby School Superintendent Richard F. Dunlap, Jr., Ed. D., at a recent Pre-K for PA news conference.  “Education investment must start early before the achievement gap is too wide and expensive to overcome.”

The new poll confirms that the risks of under-investing are too dangerous for inaction in Harrisburg to continue.  Along with the poll, evidence of the impact of high quality early learning programs continues to mount.  Last year 4-year-olds in Pennsylvania’s publicly supported pre-k programs achieved dramatic gains in academic and social proficiency.  It is clear that the public support is there, and in an election year, the Legislature is likely to notice.  Pennsylvanians are strong believers that every child benefits when all children enter school readying to learn.  The question is: will candidates and elected officials take notice?

Thursday, January 23, 2014

Staving Off Another Philadelphia School Funding Crisis Starts with City Council

Lately, the coming of spring means Philadelphians can count on three things: high hopes for the Phils in Clearwater, taxes coming due and the shortchanging of the School District of Philadelphia.  If last year looked bad, this year looks worse.  The District is going to need another $300—possibly $400—million to open doors in 2014.

The school district’s budget is still out of balance in spite of the poorly constructed state plan of one-time federal funding and public school building sales that resulted in only $2 million of the $120 million needed by the School District on an ongoing basis.  While taking very little out of the State’s coffers, the Governor pushed through a plan to direct one percent of the City’s current sales tax to the school district.  That’s a plan that could bring the District $120 million annually, if approved by City Council.

Although the district has lost millions in state aid since 2011, last August the Council President’s office spokesperson said, “Council will pass an extension of the sales tax."  But to date nothing has moved.  In December, PCCY and members of a broad coalition of education advocacy organizations gave the Legislature at “D” and City Council a “C-” for failing to do all that was expected for the schools.  The groups called on Council to approve the sales tax transfer by March 31st.  The goal of the Coalition is to push City Council to act so that Harrisburg can not use local inaction as an excuse to for failing to appropriate a reasonable level of state aid to the School District.

Like it or not, this is Philadelphia’s problem.  Of the more than 250 legislators in Harrisburg, only 35 have districts that include part of Philadelphia. Therefore, most of the state’s elected officials feel indifferent at best to our local funding problems.  That’s why Philadelphia City Council needs to make the first move.  Doing so can be a peace signal to the state that Philadelphians are willing to do their part.

At the same time, it’s clear that the state isn’t exactly volunteering to help; in fact, the Governor’s office is already crying poor.  Budget Secretary Charles Zogby has projected a $1.4 billion deficit that will require cuts, new revenues or a combination of the two,” the AP reports.  If they’re so hard up for cash, why did the Governor push a plan to cut the corporate tax rate by nearly a third starting next year?  According to the PA Budget and Policy Center, in 2003-2004 the cost of corporate tax breaks for the state was $850 million.  Last year it was $3.2 billion.  Moreover, previous budget estimates by the Governor’s Budget office have shown that they are prone to exaggerate projected expenditures and dramatically undercount expected revenues.

What is needed is a grand bargain.  All politics is a “give and take” process.  Making the first move and approving the sales tax shift while urging the state to approve the cigarette tax increase that already passed City Council to meet Philadelphia’s pension costs may be a face-saving way to get these unfriendly partners to begin to work together.

The administration has signaled a willingness to raise education spending, but it’s not clear that they are willing to put any reliable new money on the table.  According to the Inquirer, “Corbett will not be proposing new revenue sources to cover the investment.”  His idea is reportedly to find the money in pension savings.  Even his own party leaders are doubtful the Governor will get it done.  “It will be interesting to see how it is accomplished,” said Senate Appropriations Chair Jake Corman, “given an anticipated $1.5 billion in new costs for pensions, Medicaid and prisons.  The prospect of $100 million in pension savings ‘is a step in the right direction,’ Corman said, ‘but we will need substantial revenue or savings above that to invest in education.’” 

Like it or not, with state money in too short a supply, the sales tax for schools is an opportunity that City Council cannot afford to have pass them by.  Things have gotten beyond bad enough already.  PCCY recently learned that there are only 16 librarians in the entire district and, alarmingly, only one nurse for every 866 children and one counselor for every 600 students.  We cannot let this become the status quo.  But if City Council does not take action on the sales tax and $120 million of annual revenue, these sorts of school horrors might be the least of our worries.

Friday, January 10, 2014

When Covering All Kids Doesn't Cover All Kids

Every child in Pennsylvania deserves access to proper healthcare.  This should not be a controversial idea.  Yet while millions of Americans will get access to healthcare in 2014 through the Affordable Care Act, tens of thousands of PA kids are being turned away, purposely left out of the system.  This is unacceptable and must change.

In 2006, the Pennsylvania legislature enacted reform to “Cover All Kids” under the CHIP program.  Except “All Kids” doesn’t really mean all kids.  The legislation exempts children living in Pennsylvania who are immigrants whose families entered the United States without proper documentation.  That’s 47,000 kids that the state would rather see suffer than get proper medical attention.  “Children have no control over their parent’s choice to bring them lawfully or unlawfully into the country,” PCCY’s Health Policy Director Colleen McCauley testified at a Healthy PA hearing in January.  “Consequently, children should not be penalized for the actions of their parents and should be afforded coverage through CHIP.”

It gets worse.  “Immigrants who are in the U.S. illegally cannot participate in the system,” the Altoona Mirror reported in December.  “But many have eligible relatives who are citizens or legal residents.”  However, due to fear of repercussions from immigration officials, many undocumented immigrants will not seek healthcare coverage for their eligible citizen children.  The legislature does have the ability to change this.  “The healthcare options available to the most needy immigrants are limited, and vary widely from state to state,” the Atlantic wrote.  “States have the option of using federal funds to provide prenatal care to pregnant women whose lack of legal status makes them ineligible for Medicaid, and the Children's Health Insurance Program provides coverage to nearly 8 million children (not just immigrants) in families with incomes too high to qualify for Medicaid. Even so, the fear of deportation scares qualified families away.”  By making it illegal for undocumented immigrants to obtain health care, we block an uncountable number of eligible children from it.

But this isn’t about numbers; it’s about children.  Children like “Elena.” Elena is ten years old and desperately needs a tooth pulled and a root canal, but her parents cannot afford these dental procedures.  A school nurse helped refer her to a mobile dentist who provides free care, but the procedures she needs are too complicated for them to handle.  Since Elena is not eligible for CHIP or Medicaid under state law, she is forced to live with chronic mouth pain that affects her ability to concentrate in school.  Elena did not choose to come here; she should not be punished for a decision she did not make.  Her immigration status should not matter, all that matters is there is a child in pain and we are making a choice not to help her.

Healthy PA has made some progress for children by reauthorizing CHIP and eliminating a waiting period for some children.  While Healthy PA has taken a step in the right direction, it is not a large enough one.  The Inquirer reported Thursday that “Corbett’s proposal to insure an estimated 500,000 people, part of his broader ‘Healthy Pennsylvania’ plan, would not take effect until 2015, at a loss of $7 million to $10 million a day in federal funds.”  State Rep. Mike Sturla said, “I don’t think there is any way that you can look at the current proposal and see it as anything other than a stall tactic.”  Healthy PA is not a solution until everyone is covered.   “Pennsylvania should not compromise children’s healthy wellbeing by limiting their access to health care services,” testified Dr. Judith Silver, a pediatric psychologist at Children’s Hospital of Philadelphia and Vice President of PCCY’s Board of Directors.  “Cover All Kids” and Healthy PA have been a good start, but they do not go far enough.  Action must be taken in Harrisburg to ensure that every Pennsylvania gets access to the healthcare they need.


Get involved.  Sign up for PCCY's E-Alerts at www.pccy.org/joinus

Wednesday, December 11, 2013

Chester County is Nice… Depending on Who You Ask

Chester County is a nice place to live.  Throughout the recession, the median family income never dropped below $100,000.  In 2010, the Inquirer reported that Chester County was among the 25 richest counties in the nation.  That’s out of more than 3,000 counties.  On the whole, the financial situation in Chester County is a good one.  But when we look a little deeper we find a troubling trend: while things are fine at the top of the economic spectrum, things are getting worse at the low end—especially for children.

While the median family income in Chester County is within 1% of where it was in 2008, the number of children living in poverty has increased 55% in that period.  Of those children living in poverty, nearly half of them are living in deep poverty, below half the poverty line.  That’s less than $12,000 a year for a family of four.  But why focus on children?  Because poverty does not affect everyone equally; in Chester County, the poverty rate for children is nearly 50% higher than that of seniors.  Children make up less than a quarter of the county’s population, but almost half of its population receiving food stamps.



Children make up such a large percentage of those receiving food stamps because their enrollment in the Supplemental Nutrition Assistance Program (SNAP) jumped 56% from FY 2009-10 to 20012-13.  Unfortunately, SNAP benefits were reduced in November 2013, leading a family of four, on average, to lose 21 meals per month.  There are other programs available to ensure children receive the nutrition they need, including the National School Lunch Program (NSLP) and the School Breakfast Program (SBP).  Regrettably, while the number of Chester County students eligible for free or reduced-price meals has increased 27% since 2008, participation rates in NSLP and SBP have actually dropped.  In fact, while every school district in the county saw its number of eligible students rise, none serve breakfast to more than a third of those eligible.  The number of eligible students more than doubled in the Unionville-Chadds Ford School District, yet they serve breakfast to less than 5% of those eligible for the program.


One of the problems of living in such an affluent county is that there can be a stigma attached to enrolling in supplemental assistance programs, such as signing up your children for free or reduced-price school meals.  With low pre-recession unemployment rates, Chester County is not used to dealing with so many people in need, people at the low-end of the economic spectrum who were hit much harder than the majority of the county.  It is imperative that schools and local municipalities do whatever they can to ensure that their students get the nutrition they need, whether this means changing the time, location and method of service of breakfast or reaching out to parents with the benefits of enrollment.  It is true that taken as a whole, things look good for Chester County; but it won’t truly be good until that can be said about every child in the county.

Thursday, December 5, 2013

Heading in the Wrong Direction: More Delaware County Children Suffer from Hunger and Poverty

In Delaware County, children—particularly young children—are more likely to be living in poverty than any other age group.  The number of economically disadvantaged students continues to rise, and Delco school districts are struggling to meet their needs.  To fully understand the problem, we must delve deeper into food insecurity in Delaware County.

Since 2008, the share of children in poverty in Delaware County has increased 30% and the number of students eligible for free and reduced price school meals increased 20%.  But there’s a difference between recognizing a need and fulfilling it.  In 2012, 12 of Delaware County’s 15 school districts served school breakfast to less than a quarter of eligible students.  The Springfield School District has seen a nearly 80% rise in the number students eligible for free or reduced price meals; looking closer, we find only 8% of eligible students were served breakfast.  But the most egregious district is Marple Newtown, where the number of eligible students more than doubled.  Marple Newtown does not offer a breakfast program.



In fact, countywide, participation in school meals has actually dropped since 2008, despite the rise in need.  Only two out of three eligible students receive lunch, a nearly 10% drop, while participation in school breakfast has dropped five percent to less than a third of eligible students.  Of course, school isn’t the only place where children need assistance with food.  The number of Delaware County children enrolled in SNAP (food stamps) increased 31% in the last three years to the point where children make up more than two out of every five SNAP participants in Delco, despite being less than a quarter of the population.  Unfortunately, as of November 1st, SNAP benefits were reduced so that Delaware County families will lose an estimated $6.7 million in benefits in the coming year.



For the 16% of Delaware County children experiencing food insecurity, the problems don’t end with being hungry in class.  Ultimately, food insecurity exacts a huge cost as it contributes to a greater likelihood of limited employability, lessened workforce productivity, poorer job performance, and $260,000 lower lifetime earnings.  “A growing number of parents all across Delaware County are having trouble putting food on the table for their children,” said Kathy Fisher, PCCY’s family economic security director for PCCY.  “Now, more than ever, it is important for county leaders to do everything they can so children don't go hungry in Delaware County.”

Hunger doesn’t come out of nowhere.  Food insecurity is not caused solely by a lack of access to benefits.  If people can afford proper nutrition, they’ll supply it for their children.  While the nation has spent the last four years pulling itself out of the recession, the median income in Delaware County is actually $5,600 less than it was in 2008.  As you may have imagined, families on the lower end of the economic spectrum were hit the worst.  One in four families in Delco makes less than $45,000 a year, up 23% since 2008. The best strategy for reducing childhood hunger and food insecurity is a job that pays a decent wage for parents.  If our legislators don’t take action to help get these families back on their feet, there’s little hope for children who don’t have enough on their plates.